← Back to In Movies

Movie vs. Book

The Return of Dogtanian (1989)

The Return of Dogtanian
1989 · BRB Internacional & Wang Film Productions
Production: BRB Internacional, Televisión Española, Thames Television
Animation: Wang Film Productions
Format: Animated series · Based on: The Vicomte de Bragelonne
View on IMDb →
Synopsis: Ten years after the original series, this sequel adapts material from The Vicomte de Bragelonne, reworking the Man in the Iron Mask conspiracy as a golden muzzle concealing the king's secret evil twin, as Dogtanian and his companions confront a threat to the crown itself.

A direct sequel to the beloved 1981 series discussed elsewhere on this site, this continuation follows the same basic strategy that made its predecessor work: adapting real Dumas plot material, in this case Twenty Years After rather than the first novel, through an animal-cast lens aimed at a young audience, rather than inventing an entirely new, unrelated story.

A Genuine Attempt at Later Saga Material, Not Just More Adventures

Unlike some franchise sequels that simply continue a beloved property with unrelated new plots, this series specifically adapts material from The Vicomte de Bragelonne, the final volume of Dumas's d'Artagnan trilogy, built around Aramis's conspiracy involving the king's secret twin. The show reworks the novel's iron mask into a golden muzzle fitted to the animal cast, retaining the core premise of a hidden royal double while adapting its specific device to the series' established animal-kingdom visual logic.

A Changed Production Pipeline

Where the original series was animated in Japan by Nippon Animation, this sequel shifted animation duties to Wang Film Productions, a Taiwanese studio, while retaining Spanish producer BRB Internacional's creative involvement alongside new British co-production partner Thames Television. This kind of shifting international production arrangement was common for children's animation of this era, and it means the sequel's visual style, while recognizably continuous with the original, was produced through a different pipeline than its predecessor.

A Compilation Film Followed in 1995

BRB Internacional later released a feature-length television film, Dogtanian: One For All and All For One, edited together from episodes of this sequel series, a common practice for children's animated properties of the era, repackaging serialized television content into a more marketable single-viewing format for later broadcast or video release.

A Less Fondly Remembered Sequel

Unlike the original 1981 series, which retains a true, enduring cult following across the Spanish, French, and Latin American markets where it originally aired, this sequel is generally remembered with less affection by fans of the franchise, a common pattern for animated sequels made years after an original's cultural peak, working with reduced budgets and a changed creative team while trying to extend a beloved property's commercial life. The shift to a new animation studio likely contributed to this reception, since visual consistency with a beloved original is often exactly the quality longtime fans notice first when it changes.

The Same Iron Mask Story, Told for a Younger Audience

As discussed in this site's own comparisons of the 1939 and 1998 Man in the Iron Mask films, the twin-conspiracy material at the end of the d'Artagnan saga has proven durable across wildly different adaptations, formats, and target audiences, from live-action prestige films to an animated children's series continuing its own established animal-cast continuity, all drawn to the same central premise of a hidden royal double.

Read the source material at The Vicomte de Bragelonne, or see the original Dogtanian and the Three Muskehounds and the later 2021 feature film remake for the full arc of this animal-cast franchise across four decades.

Advertisement